| Year | Pro Winner | Farm Winner |
|---|---|---|
| 24 | New York Rangers |  Rockford IceHogs |
| 24 | New York Rangers | Rockford IceHogs |
| 24 | New York Rangers | Rockford IceHogs |
| 24 | New York Rangers | Rockford IceHogs |
| 24 | New York Rangers | Rockford IceHogs |
| 24 | New York Rangers | Rockford IceHogs |
| 24 | New York Rangers | Rockford IceHogs |
| 24 | New York Rangers | Rockford IceHogs |